Clean Brands

Is Commodity a Clean Brand? Investigating Their Cruelty-Free and Vegan Claims

4 Mins read

Commodity, a fragrance and personal care brand, provides a range of unique products that are designed to make individuals feel and smell their very best. Over recent years, Commodity has gained popularity for marketing itself as a ‘clean’, ‘cruelty-free’, and ‘vegan’ brand. These claims have garnered the attention of consumers who are seeking to align their buying habits with their ethical standards.

Guided by their sustainability ethos, Commodity insists that they are committed to creating cruelty-free products that cause no harm to animals. They also claim that their formulations are devoid of any animal-derived ingredients, hence qualifying as vegan. Furthermore, they promote themselves as a ‘clean’ brand, implying that their products are free from potentially harmful chemicals.

While the brand’s ethical stance is commendable, it raises important questions – are these claims true and substantiated, or are they a mere marketing gimmick? This article aims to investigate Commodity’s claims by delving deep into what these terms mean, examining product ingredients, and seeking expert opinions.

Understanding The Terms: What Does ‘Clean’, ‘Cruelty-Free’ and ‘Vegan’ Really Mean?

When a brand claims to be ‘clean’, it generally means that their products are made without ingredients that have been linked to harmful health effects. So ‘clean’ should mean safe, non-toxic, and free from harmful chemicals. However, it’s important to note that there is no regulated definition of ‘clean’ in the cosmetics industry, which leaves room for brands to define it as they see fit.

‘Cruelty-free’, on the other hand, has a more concrete definition. It means that the products and their ingredients have not been tested on animals at any stage of product development. And ‘vegan’ products are those that do not contain any animal-derived ingredients or by-products.

SEE ALSO:  Is bareMinerals a Clean Brand? Investigating Their Cruelty-Free and Vegan Claims

In the world of ethical consumerism, these terms play a crucial role. They allow consumers to make informed decisions about the products they purchase, ensuring that their buying habits align with their personal ethics and values.

Commodity: Professing A Commitment to Being Cruelty-Free

Commodity has asserted that they are a cruelty-free brand. This means that they claim not to test their products on animals at any stage of product development, nor do they allow third-parties or suppliers to conduct animal testing on their behalf.

To confirm this claim, it is usually reliable to look for certifications from recognized bodies such as Leaping Bunny or PETA. These organizations thoroughly vet brands to ensure they meet rigorous cruelty-free standards. However, Commodity has yet to secure any official certifications.

While this doesn’t automatically disqualify them from being cruelty-free, it does mean that consumers must take their claims on trust. Without certification, there is a certain lack of transparency regarding Commodity’s animal testing policies.

Are Commodity’s Products Truly Vegan? A Deep Dive

Commodity claims that all their products are completely free from animal-derived ingredients, making them vegan. To substantiate this claim, we must scrutinize the ingredient lists of their products.

For instance, a typical Commodity product, the ‘Book Eau de Parfum’, lists ingredients such as Bergamot, Cypress, and Sandalwood, which are all plant-derived. However, it’s the less familiar components like Diisostearyl Malate and Cinnamal that can potentially be animal-derived.

SEE ALSO:  Is Saint Jane a Clean Brand? Investigating Their Cruelty-Free and Vegan Claims

Without complete transparency about the origin of these ingredients, it becomes challenging to definitively confirm if all Commodity’s products are 100% vegan. Therefore, while no obvious animal-derived ingredients are listed, the brand’s vegan claims remain somewhat ambiguous.

Testing The Claims: Commodity’s Ingredient Investigation

To further investigate Commodity’s claims, we delved deep into the specifics of their product ingredients. The brand does list all ingredients for each product on their website, allowing consumers to know exactly what they are using.

In general, Commodity’s products appear to be free from controversial ingredients like parabens, phthalates, and sulfates, aligning with their ‘clean’ brand claim. However, some products contain ingredients like ‘fragrance’ or ‘perfume’, which can be a catch-all term for undisclosed chemicals.

While these aren’t necessarily harmful, the lack of clarity does raise questions about the brand’s commitment to complete transparency, which is an essential element of being a ‘clean’ brand.

What The Experts Say: Interviews with Industry Insiders

To gather more insights, we reached out to several industry experts. Dr. Anjali Mahto, a consultant dermatologist, shared her views on the ‘clean’ beauty trend: “The term ‘clean’ is not regulated and can be used freely by brands. While it’s great that brands are avoiding potentially harmful ingredients, consumers should always check product labels for themselves.”

SEE ALSO:  Is stila a Clean Brand? Investigating Their Cruelty-Free and Vegan Claims

Similarly, Cruelty Free International representative, Lucy Siegle, emphasized on the importance of cruelty-free certifications: “While a brand’s own claims are a good start, third-party certifications provide an extra layer of assurance that the products are genuinely cruelty-free.”

The Verdict: Are Commodity’s Claims Justifiable?

In light of our investigation, it appears that Commodity’s claims of being a ‘clean’ and ‘cruelty-free’ brand are generally justifiable, despite the lack of official certifications. Their ingredient lists show a clear effort to avoid potentially harmful chemicals, aligning with the generally accepted understanding of ‘clean’ beauty.

However, their vegan claims are less certain. Without transparency about the sources of all their ingredients, it’s hard to definitively confirm that all their products are indeed vegan.

Reflection and The Way Forward for Ethical Consumerism

This investigation underscores the importance of transparency and regulation in the beauty industry. Brands like Commodity, who make bold ethical claims, need to provide clear, substantiated evidence to back them up.

While Commodity seems to uphold its ‘clean’ and ‘cruelty-free’ claims, their ‘vegan’ status remains uncertain. This highlights the need for brands to not only make ethical commitments but also to provide the necessary transparency that allows consumers to make truly informed choices.

Ultimately, ethical consumerism is not just about brands making commitments; it’s about consumers demanding transparency and holding brands accountable. It’s a two-way street that can lead us towards a more sustainable and ethical future.